Site icon

Major Pivots in Medicaid Community Engagement Implementation Announced as Go-Live Date

Lawsuit and justice concept, Lawyer working with partner at law firm. legal consulting discussion defendant punishment law in courtroom.

Major Pivots in Medicaid Community Engagement Implementation Announced as Go-Live Date Approaches

Recent weeks have brought two important developments related to the new federal Medicaid community engagement requirements (CER). In late October, a federal court struck down a narrower medical frailty exemption included in the June 2026 CER Interim Final Rule (IFR). Shortly thereafter, on November 13th, the Center for Medicare and Medicaid Services (CMS) issued a State Medicaid Director Letter (SMDL) establishing an optional hold harmless period to support state implementation efforts. This article provides an overview of both policy developments and their implications for states.

Federal Court Strikes Down CMS Restrictions on Medical Frailty Exemption Under H.R. 1

As HPN previously reported, on June 29, 2026, 25 states and D.C. sued CMS, challenging multiple provisions in the agency’s CER IFR as violations of Administrative Procedures Act (APA) and the Spending Clause of the U.S. Constitution. The lawsuit focused on three provisions: (1) CMS’s interpretation of the statutory definition of “medically frail,” (2) the IFR’s 12-month lookback period for claims data used to assess medical frailty, and (3) limits on the use of self-attestations.

On October 29, just two months before community engagement requirements go into effect, a U.S. District Court Judge issued a summary judgement decision, upholding the 12-month lookback period for claims data and the limited use of self-attestations, while overruling the more limited medical frailty test.

The court first considered whether CMS exceeded its authority by narrowing the statutory definition of “medically frail.” Under the IFR, an individual would qualify for an exemption from CER as medically frail only if they both have a physical, mental, or other behavioral health condition within the one of the five statutory categories and that condition significantly impairs their ability to comply with CER. Plaintiff states challenged this as an unconstitutional change to the H.R. 1 definition of medically frailty, which stated that medically frail individuals “include” those with conditions within five specified subcategories, without requiring any additional tests.

The court rejected CMS’s interpretation, finding CMS’s argument that the categories serve as examples and do not automatically encompass every individual who falls within them unpersuasive and noting that the states’ argument was supported by H.R. 1’s broader structure and purpose. According to the court, Congress intended the listed categories to establish a minimum definition of medical frailty from which CMS lacked discretion to depart. The court further noted that other community engagement exemptions created by H.R. 1 function categorically and do not require individuals to demonstrate an inability to comply with CER, Congress included functional limitations elsewhere in the statute when it intended such limitations to apply, and the legislative history of H.R. 1 supports the conclusion that anyone falling within one of the statutory categories should be considered medically frail, without additional restrictions.

On the other hand, the court rejected the states’ challenges to the 12-month claims lookback period and the restrictions on the use of self-attestations, finding that those provisions fell “well short” of being arbitrary or capricious under the APA.

The court vacated the challenged language related to the definition of medical frailty, granted the states’ request for a permanent injunction against that provision, and ordered a six-month stay on penalties issued against plaintiff states for errors or delays in implementing the IFR.

While CMS may appeal the ruling, the decision marks an important development in the implementation of H.R. 1’s community engagement requirements and presents states with challenging decisions to make as they prepare for implementation.

Optional Hold Harmless Period for Community Engagement Implementation

In response to state concerns regarding the operational challenges associated with implementing community engagement requirements, CMS issued a SMDL just last week providing states an optional six-month “hold harmless” period. For initial applications received and renewals begun through June 30, 2027, states that elect this option may temporarily refrain from denying eligibility or disenrolling individuals who do not demonstrate compliance with community engagement requirements. During this period, CMS will not take “enforcement action” against states that suspend eligibility denials and disenrollments based on an individual’s failure to document that they comply with community engagement requirements, qualify for an exemption, or meet the criteria for an exclusion.

Importantly, the hold harmless period does not delay implementation of CER. States are still expected to operationalize community engagement requirements during this time, including assessing compliance with CER or eligibility for exclusion or exception – as well as testing eligibility and reporting systems, validating processes for identifying exemptions and exclusions, and assessing staffing, training, and administrative capacity needs before full enforcement begins on July 1, 2027. CMS believes this will allow states to test and refine their systems and processes and address workforce needs before operationalizing the eligibility impact.

In addition to having the option of whether to avail themselves of the hold harmless option, states may choose a shorter time period or seek approval of other mitigation strategies. States wishing to opt-in to the hold harmless period must include it as an optional strategy in the mitigation plan submitted to CMS by December 11, 2026.

Health Policy News will continue to monitor litigation and federal guidance on H.R. 1 generally and provide updates as they become available.

Exit mobile version